Serving Essex, Passaic, Middlesex, Bergen, Union County and Hudson Counties for over 20 years, call 24 hours a day.
Private Pay, Long-Term Care Insurance, and Veterans Benefits Accepted

Senior Care News

Should You Hire a Private Caregiver or Use a Home Health Care Agency in NJ?

You have already decided to get a caregiver for yourself or your elderly loved one. However, you are torn between hiring a private caregiver or acquiring the services of a home health care agency. Which is better? Which option is best for you? Let us find out.

Both options allow you to receive care in a safe, comfortable and familiar environment, your home. However, each has its own advantages and disadvantages. Knowing the differences and the pros and cons gives you a better view of what arrangement works best for you. Ultimately, you must choose what is best for your loved one. 

Hiring a Private Caregiver

This option means that you will directly hire a caregiver. If you choose this option, bear in mind that you will become the employer of the private caregiver. This means that you will have to consider the payroll, taxes, and liability issues such as insurance and workers’ compensation. Since you are the employer, you can be held responsible if something happens to the caregiver while performing his or her job.

What is involved in directly hiring a private caregiver?

When you directly hire a caregiver, you will have to consider and take care of the following:

  • Directly hiring a caregiver means that you will have to conduct background checks yourself. 
  • Doing all the work in processing the payroll, withholding the taxes, social security, and the like.
  • Making sure that your insurance covers liability insurance in case something happens, such as abuse, theft, or fraud, among others.
  • Checking the work experience of the prospective private caregiver. This means that you will have to make sure that you check all the work history, training, certificates, and references of the caregiver you’re hiring.


On top of these, you will also have to worry about the scheduling. You need to make sure that another caregiver will fill in in case of a last-minute change in schedule, or in case the caregiver quits without a warning or won’t show up on the scheduled shift. If you think you can manage all these, then you may hire a private caregiver for
elderly in home care.

At-Home Health Care Agency

On the contrary, choosing a home care agency means less responsibility and stress on your part. The agency will take care of everything: from background checks, employee screening, training, certification, taxes, to liability issues. You won’t have to worry about these things. It is the agency that will supervise and manage their caregivers. A backup caregiver will also be provided in case your regular caregiver cannot come on schedule or in case of emergencies.

Benefits of Home Care Agency

There are plenty of benefits when you opt to use the services of a home care agency. These include the following:

  • The caregivers are thoroughly selected. They undergo rigorous background checks and a selection process.
  • Home care agencies provide extensive training to their caregivers. This is to ensure that the caregivers are well-trained to provide general care and specialized care. They are trained to work within individualized care plans to make sure that all the needs of the client are met with satisfaction.
  • The caregivers are well-supervised. They receive strict supervision and helpful administrative assistance. The agency reviews the quality of care provided and the overall performance of each caregiver. 
  • The home care agency will handle all the administrative work, such as scheduling, billing, workers’ compensation, taxes, and more.
  • You get to meet prospective caregivers and choose the one you feel is best for your elderly loved one. If in the event that you are not satisfied with the caregiver’s service, you can always ask for a replacement from the agency.
  • The agency will send another caregiver in case the regular caregiver calls in sick or is not available due to an emergency. This ensures continuity of in home senior care.
  • Quality home care agencies have the necessary certifications and are compliant with federal regulations. This serves as an assurance and protection to clients and their families.


All things considered, it appears that acquiring the services of a home care agency has plenty of advantages over hiring a private caregiver. Perhaps the biggest consideration is that you will not have to worry about a lot of things when you secure the services of an agency since they will already take care of everything. 

By choosing a home care agency, you will have less stress in your life. You can have peace of mind knowing that everything is in order and that your loved one is being taken care of with compassion. You have a lot of safeguards. You can rest assured that the caregiver taking care of your loved one has the necessary experience, trainings and skills, and has gone through a rigorous background check.

Home Health Care Providers in NJ

Do you need a home care agency in New Jersey? Astir Home Health Care provides a wide range of quality home care services in various counties of New Jersey. We provide care home care in Essex, Passaic, Middlesex, Bergen and Hudson. Our team of professional caregivers are well-trained, highly skilled, dedicated, hardworking, trustworthy, and compassionate. They will treat you like family.

Give us a call or visit us and we will discuss your personalized care. We will provide you with the care that you deserve. Contact us today!

Recent Posts

Categories

Contact Us About Home Care

Skip to content